Protecting the Water Way

 is a Fallout 3 quest that is added to the game in the Broken Steel downloadable content pack.

Walkthrough
Scribe Bigsley will ask the Lone Wanderer to investigate the organized bandit attacks on the Aqua Pura caravans, directing The Lone Wanderer to speak with Officer Lepelletier of Rivet City to learn more details about the attacks.

Lepelletier can be found on the ramp leading to Rivet City, and explains that a water caravan heading towards Canterbury Commons that has just left the Jefferson Memorial. The Lone Wanderer is asked to catch up with it, talk with Officers Davis and Lorin and guard it from attack.

Following the river around will lead the player to the caravan as it is in ambush by three bandits (it seems to be almost impossible to save most of the lives of the caravan, and both Davis and Lorin could be dead by the time the Lone Wanderer arrives).

Upon searching any of the bandits the player will find an audio log titled New Meeting Place from Split Jack the bandit leader, instructing the bandits to group at Wilhelm's Wharf. When reaching Wilhelm's Warf, the Lone Wanderer can either speak to Split Jack (the password is 'Mirelurk Stew') and pass a difficult speech challenge to persuade him to give up or else kill him (killing the three bandits with him is optional for the quest). Please note that if the speech check is passed successfully then Grandma Sparkle is likely to be immediately killed by the bandits.

Lepelletier thanks the player for their assistance, but is unable to reward them. The wanderer is advised to speak to Scribe Bigsley in order to receive the reward - some captured Enclave gear - Enclave Power Armor and Helmet, a Gatling Laser, a Plasma Pistol and ammo for the same.

Alternatively, you can join the bandits. All you have to do is speak with Split Jack. He will give you Metal Armor and a Metal Helmet. He will then ask you to put them on because if you want to be in the gang you have to wear Metal Armor. He then asks you to speak with Lepelletier about a protection contract. You can then go to Lepelletier and blackmail her for 500 caps after succeeding a speech check. You can also tell her that you want 500 caps now, and 500 caps after the attacks have stopped. She will soon after become hostile and attack you.

If you join their gang you can talk to Jack and challenge him, he will give you the option of what weapons melee weapons to fight with (Lead pipes, combat knives, and a few others). So long as you fight him with the weapon you chose none of the gang members will attack and will cheer on the fight. When you win they will say that they dont want to have another leader but want you to ask Lepelletier about the protection contract.


 * NOTE - If you have followers, they will join you in the fight with Jack, causing his crew to attack as well. Tell them to wait FAR AWAY or they will rush in and start shooting.  Also, the Mysterious Stranger counts as an ally, and if he appears in V.A.T.S., the rest of the gang will attack you.


 * NOTE - Not sure about anyone else but I only received 100 XP for completing this quest. I did not try any speech checks and only killed Split Jack, none of the bandits.

Bugs
After challenging Split Jack to a knife fight for some reason the knife cannot be dropped, fixed or unequipped. It may be due to picking up the combat knife off of Split Jack's corpse. After dropping his knife, it was possible to drop the bugged knife.