Caravan (game)

Caravan is a card game designed by Obsidian Entertainment specifically for Fallout: New Vegas.

Inside of game
While traveling throughout the Mojave Wasteland, you will encounter NPCs who will be available to play a game of Caravan. In order to play Caravan you must possess a full deck (30+ cards), however the dialogue option appears even if you don't have enough cards. (PS3, 360 and PC confirmed) If an attempt is made to play with an insufficient number of cards, a message appears informing the player they need at least 30 cards to play a hand of Caravan.

Obtaining a deck
A free 54 card deck and game instructions can be received from Ringo in Goodsprings. Additional cards can also be obtained from various stores and merchants across the Mojave wasteland.

Building A Deck
Caravan decks are composed of at least 30 cards from one or more traditional playing card sets. The deck may have any number of cards of any type that suits a player's strategy, although it cannot have duplicate cards from the same set. For example, a King of Spades from Set A and a King of Spades from Set B is acceptable, but more than one King of Spades from Set A would be illegal.

Rules
Caravan is played with two players building three opposing piles (or "caravans") of numbered cards. The goal is to outbid your opponent's caravan with the highest value of numbered cards without being too light (under 21) or overburdened (over 26). The game begins with each player taking eight cards from their deck and placing either one numerical card or ace on each caravan. Players may NOT discard during this initial round.

Once both players have started their three caravans, each player may do ONE of the following on their turn:

1. Play one card and draw a new card from his deck into his hand.

2. Discard one card from his hand and draw a new card from his deck.

3. Disband one of his three caravans by removing all cards from that pile.

Caravans have a direction, either ascending or descending numerically, and a suit. The suit is determined with the first card placed on the caravan, the direction by the second. All subsequent cards must continue the numerical direction or match the suit of the previous card. Cards of the same numerical value cannot be played in sequence, regardless of suit. Face cards can be attached to numeric cards in any caravan and affect them in various ways.

Card Values

 * Joker: Played against Ace; 2-10.
 * Effects change based on whether it's an ace or a number (see below). Multiple jokers may be played on the same card.


 * Ace: Value of 1.
 * Jokers played on aces remove all other non-face cards of the ace's suit from the table. e.g. a joker played on an Ace of Spades removes all spades (except face cards and that card, specifically) from the table.


 * Numbered Cards (2-10): Listed value.
 * Jokers played on these cards remove all other cards of this value from the table. Eg. a joker played on a 4 of Hearts removes all 4s (other than that card, specifically) from the table.


 * Jack: Played against Ace; 2-10.
 * Removes that card, along with any face cards attached to it.


 * Queen: Played against Ace; 2-10.
 * Reverses the current direction of the hand and changes the current suit of the hand. Multiple queens may be played on the same card.


 * King: Played against Ace; 2-10.
 * Adds the value of that card again. Eg. a king played on a 9 adds 9 to that pile. Multiple kings may be played on the same card for multiplicative effects; that is to say, a second King will add the doubled value resulting from the first King. So 4+King=8, but 4+King+King=16 (8 plus 8)

Winning
A player's caravan is considered sold when the value of its cards is over 20 and under 27. The other player may still outbid by increasing the value of their opposing pile while staying within the 21-26 range. When each of the three competing caravans has sold, the game is over. In the event of a tie between two matched caravans, the game continues until all three caravans have sold. The player with two or more sales wins the pot.

Clarifications
The official instructions are a little brief. For players having trouble playing, always seeing the card red when trying to add it to the caravan, note that you have to press DOWN in order to put it UNDER the caravan. A more thorough explanation can be found below.

Winning condition in plain English
Winning is easy to understand if you grasp the fact that the tech writer who wrote the official rules goofed a very important point of clarity: there are only three caravans on the board. Your three piles on your side are your bids for each caravan, and likewise for your opponent. Six bids, three caravans. As soon as all three caravans are sold, the game ends. The player who has the highest bid on at least two of the caravans at game end wins the pot.

A caravan is sold when at least one of its bids falls between the range of 21 - 26 AND the bids for that caravan are different amounts. Until all three caravans are sold, either player can keep adjusting the bids on any caravan! Only when all three meet the "sold" criteria does play stop and you determine who has two or more of the highest bids within the 21 - 26 range.

Now here's the tricky part: a caravan with tied bids (e.g. your bid and your opponent's bid add up to the same value; 25, for example) is not yet sold, so something must happen to break the tie. This can be done in many ways, such as: reducing your opponent's bid by playing a jack on one of the cards in their bid; playing a king on one of the cards in their bid to make their bid exceed 26; or say you're tied with 24 each and you discard for a few turns until you finally draw an ace and increase your bid to 25 to break the tie. Or say all three of your bids are 26 each but you opponent has one bid at 26 too, so that caravan is in a tied state. In this case you can simply wipe out your own bid (remove your stack for that caravan) and you'll instantly win the pot because the final caravan becomes sold, the game ends, and you'll have two winning bids to your opponent's one winning bid.

Opening
Each player starts out with 8 cards in his hand drawn from his deck. Players take turns placing their opening bids for each of the three caravans (i.e. columns on the table). To start a bid, a player must play any non-face card on the table, regardless of value or suit. Once both players have played their three cards regular gameplay commences. At this point there will be 3 columns and 2 rows of cards on the table.

Regular Play ('Contract War')
During a Player's turn, they can do one of the following:
 * Discard a card from their hand.
 * Discard one of their stacks from the table. (one of their bids)
 * Add to a bid. (Play a number card; i.e. Ace to 10)
 * Modify their bids or their opponent's. (Play a Face card; Jack, Queen, King or Joker)

Regardless of which option chosen, the player will draw a card afterwards, unless they already have eight cards in their hand.

Add to a Bid: Players add a number card (i.e. an Ace, or any card from 2 to 10) to one of their three columns and increase their bid. In order to add to a bid, a player plays a number card on the bottom of one of their stacks. The card must match the suit of the last card, or match the current direction. (ascending numbers or descending numbers) In both cases, the card must be a different value from the previous card.

Direction is determined by looking at the previous two cards in the column. At the beginning of the game, a player can choose to play a higher or lower value card, setting the Direction of the bid. Once there are at least two cards on a stack, those need to be checked to determine the current direction. Example: if there is a column consisting of "9-Hearts; 4-Spades; 3-Diamonds" then the direction is currently descending because 3 is smaller than 4. You could play any 2 card or any Ace. You could also play any Diamond card, except for 3-Diamonds.

Discard: A player can choose to discard either a card from their hand, and draw a new card, or discard a stack from the table. In either case, their turn immediately ends.

Modify a Bid: Face cards (Joker, Jack, Queen, King) have special abilities and can be attached, (Placed next to, rather than below) any number card currently on the table.

Example: played on a 7-Hearts this card will now be worth 14 points. If a second King is attached to it, it adds 14 (the total value) rather than 7, and the value would now be 28. Example: if there is a column consisting of "9-Hearts; 4-Spades; 3-Diamonds", attaching a "Q-Clubs" to the "3-Diamonds" means that you can now play any Clubs card, or any number card higher than 3. Example: When played against a 6-Spades, all other 6 cards regardless of their suit will be removed from the table. When played against an Ace-Diamonds all other Diamond number cards on the table will be removed.
 * King: Doubles the total value of the card(s) it attaches to.
 * Queen: Changes the column's direction and suit; an ascending bid becomes descending, and vice-versa. The bid's suit changes to match the suit of the Queen played. NOTE: The player can only play a Queen on the last card in the stack.
 * Jack: By playing this against a number card it acts as an eraser. The number card (and all its attachments) are removed from the table. This can be used on the player's bids to lower them from 27, correct a bad play made earlier, or to sabotage the opponent's bids.
 * Joker: Similar to a Jack, the Joker removes cards, but it does so on a larger scale. When played on a number card, all cards matching that number are discarded from play. When a Joker is played on an Ace, however, all cards matching the suit of the Ace are removed. The card the Joker is played on is 'spared'; it does not get removed from play.

AorCJkgie_s

Miscellaneous strategies (some rely on exploits)

 * I have found that using only two suits is easiest. For example, I personally use hearts and clubs, remember to add in all kings, jacks, jokers, and queens. You should have about 30 cards. Next you try to play at least one of both suits, this can get tricky. If you have a ten and a king at the time, be patient and play your 10 first and when you've placed your first 3 cards, play the king on the 10, you will now be 6 away from a easy win. Also remember to use your jacks on "risky" looking stacks.


 * A deck will be most effective when it contains multiple ways to make totals between 21~26 quickly. The best combinations will revolve around Kings because one won't need to worry about playing cards in order as much.  For example, when playing the combo King-10-6, one can play TK6, 6KT, T6K, or 6TK to make 22 or 26.  Playing a combo like 10-9-7 requires one to play 79T or T97.  KT8 would be a combo similar to KT6.  In addition, T86 makes 24, a strong caravan as well.  A deck with a composition of five Kings, 10's, 9's, 8's, 7's and 6's would make a very strong 30-card deck (over 50% chance of drawing a playable 3-card combo to 22~26 when drawing 3 random cards).


 * My Winning Strategy, over 90 wins in a row and counting: Before the game begins you can discard and redraw as many times as you'd like. Abuse this ability to craft the following hand.  3 Kings, 3 8's or 10's and two 8's or 10's, whichever you don't have 3 of.  Whichever card you have 3 of use as the start of each of your bids.  Then the computer will play a card on one of his bids.  You play a second card on any other bid, he plays, you play on the remaining bid.  Then use your kings to double the 8's to 26 total and win the 2 bids you're on.  If you come into a tie situation remember that you can use a king to double one of the opponents cards to cause them to go over 26.


 * Kings are almost as useful to play on your opponent's caravans as your own. A well-placed king can overburden a winning bid (e.g. TK6 -> TKK6, making a caravan of 46. The opponent's best move is probably to discard the caravan!). Additionally, when you have two winning bids, you can often win by forcing your opponent to win the third bid.


 * Using this strategy makes the game very easy. Buy from vendors as many Kings, 10s, and Jacks that you can find - then put them all in your pack when playing. When laying down the three starter cards, keep discarding any card that isn't a King, 10, 6 and Jack. When you get a 10 - lay it down on one of the caravan. Try to have 3 Kings on your hand, one or two Jokers and some other cards from 2-6. So now you should have 10s (9s or 8s) on your three caravans. As the war starts, be as quick as possible to lay down Kings. If you strike out on drawing Kings you can also lay down 9 or 8. Very quickly now you will have 20 points on at least two decks. If you now notice your opponent having a good caravan you can use Jacks to take it out. All you need to do to win is lay down some (ideally) 6s on your 20pt caravans, but anything between 2-6 obviously works. Also keep in mind you only need to win two out of three caravans to win overall.

A simple strategy (relies on exploit)
All you need to win at caravan is three 10s three 9s and three 7s. Once the game has started continue to discard your hand till you have these cards. Now build two bids (10,9,7 or 7,9,10) ignoring the caravan the computer is paying attention to. Congratulations, you will now win every time in only 6 moves.

Criticisms of this strategy:
 * This strategy is weaker than many of the strategies in the preceding section because it has no cards designed to break a tied 26 value on two or more caravans. If the computer manages to tie one of the first two caravans you build to 26, that gives it time to then build a tied 26 value on two or all three caravans. In this case, discarding one of your bids will lose the game for you. You must have a way instead, to destroy up to two of the enemy bids in the even of a 26-26 tie on all three caravans.
 * This strategy (and many of the strategies listed above in the preceding section) will work somewhat we only as long as the game bug that allows you to discard during the initial round remains in place. As soon as the game is patched to prevent this bug, this strategy will be very weak.
 * This is not a strong strategy at all if you "play fair" now for roleplay purposes and do not abuse the "discard during initial round" bug that makes this a 100% win strategy.
 * There are other 3-card combos that can work in this particular strategy: king/10/8 or king/10/6.

Overview
Note: Even if you choose to exploit the current bug that enables you to discard from your opening hand during the initial placement round (to preload your opening hand with an optimum set of cards), the following deck design is literally the strongest deck even for that exploit because every single card in it directly contributes to the fastest possible winning condition. And when (if?) Obsidian finally removes that exploit with a patch, this deck design and its accompanying gameplay methodology will yield the absolute highest probability of winning when playing by the rules, even against a very strong opponent.

Although Caravan is a fun way to make money in the game more reliably than by using the casino gambling games, it is not a balanced game for real world play because it's easy to construct a statistically "highest probable win" deck and gameplay methodology that cannot be countered except by an exactly similar "highest probable win" deck and gameplay methodology. Unlike other well-known and well-designed strategy-based card games in the real world (such as Magic:The Gathering), there is no metagame environment and no multiple counters to a currently popular winning deck/gameplay strategy.

Constraints that lead to a limited metagame
The following facts about the rules and winning conditions of Caravan lead to a clear, single "highest probable win" deck build and gameplay strategy when you are playing by the letter of the rules and not exploiting gameplay bugs such as the current ability to discard from your hand during the initial placement round. The following three concepts are used often in the explanation of this strategy. A bid of 21-25 is a "winning bid" (WB). And finally, a WB that is higher than the competing WB on a single caravan is a "high bid" (HB). A bid of 26 is a "best possible bid" (BPB), because it cannot be beaten.


 * A BPB is always superior to a HB.
 * The fastest BPB can be achieved with only three possible sets of three cards:
 * 10 + 9 + 7, but this is a weaker choice that will be explained shortly
 * 10/K + 6 (king doubles the 10)
 * 10 + 8/K (king doubles the 8)
 * A BPB tie (26 to 26) on just one caravan or more effectively stalls the winning condition until either side manages to break all of the ties. This gives both sides time to discard as needed until they can build three HBs or BPBs for all three of their bids. The first player to reach a state of all HB or BPB for each of their three bids then simply needs to break the tied bids in a manner than leaves them with 2 HBs or BPBs versus only one HB or BPB for the opponent. This yields three possible end-game scenarios:
 * One caravan is in a tied BPB state (26 to 26) and you have the HB on the other two. If it's your turn, you have the "tempo sacrifice initiative" and can remove your BPB bid, instantly winning the game.
 * Two caravans are in a tied BPB state and you have the HB on the remaining caravan. In this case, there are two ways to win:
 * Destroy both of the opponent's BPB bids, or
 * Destroy one of the opponent's BPB bids and then before they can rebuild that bid back to a BPB tie again on that caravan, remove your BPB bid on the other caravan.
 * All three caravans are in a tied BPB state. The player whose move it is has a "tempo sacrifice initiative" and can instantly win by removing one of their bids.
 * The preceding bullets add up to one very simple goal for an optimum winning deck and gameplay strategy: every single card that appears in your hand must contribute to creating BPB on your side as fast as possible OR must be able to destroy your opponent's bids. This means:
 * The two sets mentioned above that use Kings are superior to the 10 + 9 +7 set because the Kings can do double duty: they can either contribute to a BPB bid on your side by doubling either a 10 or an 8 (depending), OR they can be used to destroy an opponent's bid when necessary (by making their bid exceed 26).
 * You always want Jacks in your deck too, for extra destructive power (place on a high value card in an opponent's bid to make it drop below BPB/HB or even below any WB value at all.

Basic deck design and gameplay methodology
The constraints in the preceding section lead to only two equally strong "highest probable win" deck designs, both of which use the same exact gameplay methodology:


 * 30 total cards, comprising only Jacks, Kings, 10s, and 8s, or
 * 30 total cards, comprising only Jacks, Kings, 10s, and 6s

The trick, of course, is choosing the best number of each of the four different cards in either deck to ensure that your opening hand of 8 cards has the highest probability of being immediately useful for the initial placement round, but we'll expand on that aspect in a moment. First, let's summarize the gameplay methodology (for either of these two decks) that confers the highest probability to flexibly win when you are playing fairly by the rules (i.e., not exploiting the current bug that lets you discard indefinitely during the initial round). The only effective counter an opponent has against these two possible decks and gameplay methodology is to use exactly the same decks and gameplay methodology against you. Every other possible deck and methodology will be less effective from a probability standpoint.

Gameplay methodology consists of four simple decisions at any move, in the following priority order:


 * 1) Priority 1: Stall your opponent from creating two unopposed WB, ideally by creating an opposing BPB yourself on that same caravan, or as a last resort only, by destroying one or both of their WB with a Jack or King.
 * 2) * *Important:* Always reserve three of your total number of Kings for use in your own BPB bids! For example, if there are 8 Kings total in your deck, you can use up to 5 of them to destroy enemy bids but then you must stop using Kings as destroyers.
 * 3) * Only destroy an enemy bid in the context of this "priority one" decision process under two specific conditions:
 * 4) ** When they have one unopposed WB and a bid of 11 or higher on any other caravan AND you cannot create a BPB on your side to counter their one WP. When this occurs, you must immediately destroy their unopposed WB, because if they pull a 10 on their next turn they will instantly win. (Or in some cases, they might also be able to win if they pull a King.)
 * 5) ** You have no cards in your hand that will contribute to creating a BPB on your side. In this case, it's almost always better to destroy/slow down their highest caravan rather than to discard a Jack or a King. The only exception would be when you have only Kings to use for this purpose but laying down a king on any of the opponent caravans would create a WP or BPB on that caravan--in this case, discard a King.
 * 6) * Note that by focusing on this priority in the early game you might actually win (and quickly) in a manner similar to Priority 3 below, by simply outbidding their early WBs with two of your own BPBs.
 * 7) Priority 2: If your opponent manages to create a BPB on any caravan, strive to "stall the win" ASAP by creating a BPB tie on that same caravan (26 to 26). If you can achieve this stalled condition and maintain it (your opponent doesn't destroy your BPB on that tied caravan) long enough to get one or two more BPBs in place on your side, you will have a good chance to win the game if you can outpace your opponent on destructive moves per Priority 4 below. The main point here is that achieving and maintaining a BPB tie if your opponent pulls off an early BPB will enable you to stop worrying about both Priorities 1 and 2, simplifying your decision process to thinking only about Priorities 3 and 4.
 * 8) Priority 3: Race to create 2 unopposed BPBs (not tied) on your side. The ideal goal is to win in 4 moves after the initial round ends. For example: you lay down three 10s in the initial round, and in the next four moves you lay down an 8 below two of those 10s and the double both those 8s with the King, while your opponent is trying to build up the other, third caravan. Net result: in four moves you have two BPB versus a WB or less on two of the caravans, and your opponent has a WB or PBP bid on the third caravan versus nothing on your side. This is a winning condition for you.
 * 9) * However, you must always balance this race for BPBs against the need to stall your opponent from getting too close to a winning condition per Priorities 1 and 2.
 * 10) * If your opponent foresees your ideal strategy and attempts to block it by creating a BPB tie (26 to 26) against one of your first two caravans to ''stall the win" in their favor, then the gameplay revolves around Priority 4 below:
 * 11) Priority 4: Race to destroy tied BPBs on the opponent's side. Once you have at least two BPBs on your side per Priority 3, if you haven't already won the game (because somebody has "stalled the win" with a tied BPB), then the end game boils down to a simple race to destroy all tied BPBs in a manner where the tempo works out in your favor and you pull the winning destruction move. Remember, there are three possible ways to win this "tie destruction race" as described further up in the bullet about BPB Ties.

Detailed deck design
Okay so now that you know the ideal deck contents (two possible different decks) and the gameplay methodology for winning with those decks, what is the ideal makeup of each deck, assuming you can collect all the extra cards from various NPCs to build the ideal deck?

Exact details coming soon after I spend some time crunching the binomial probability distributions. For now, the basic idea is to load a 30-card (max) deck with a mix of Jacks, Kings, 10s, and 8s (or 6s) in a manner that yields three important highest-probability outcomes:
 * Between 3-6 cards in your opening hand of 8 cards must be numbered cards: any combination of 8s and 10s will work (or of 6s and 10s, depending on which deck you prefer).
 * Anything fewer than 3 numbered cards and you lose tempo on the initial placement round. You must be able to place a card on all three caravans in the initial round to maintain opening parity with your opponent.
 * It's okay if you have up to 6 numbers cards all of the same number (e.g., six 8s), as long as the following outcome for opening hands is also met.
 * At least two cards in your opening hand must be capable of destroying opposing bids. This means two Jacks, or any combination of Jacks and/or Kings as long as you have at least 5 Kings in your deck. This ensures a two- to four-move tempo advantage over your opponent per the Priority 1 gameplay methodology above in case they get very lucky with their opening hand.
 * Within the first 12 cards drawn from your deck, you must have at least one BPB available to create on your side, to enable meeting Priority 2 if your opponent manages to create their own BPB by their move #5 (after you've exhausted your two destroyer cards in your opening hand). As long as you can create create a "stall the win" state in response to an ultra-lucky 5th move by your opponent, you still have a very good chance of winning the game with proper play.

Bugs

 * Currently it's impossible to add purchased cards to the deck. Though this can be fixed by adding the cards to a container and then removing them from the container.
 * It is also difficult to select cards when editing your deck, because the card that's highlighted is often not the card you're selecting.
 * In game work around: Open any container or companions' backpack, put the cards from your inventory into the container or give them to your companion. Then close the container or end the trade. After this, open the container / companions' backpack again and get the cards back. The cards should now be added to your deck instead of being in your misc. inventory.
 * In some cases this workaround is impossible as, at least in my experience, the player is only capable of viewing the cards within their own inventory, when viewing a container or a companion's inventory the cards and deck are not shown, and it is therefore impossible to do anything more than throw them away.
 * Also it seems that the same bug is found on the US PS3 version of the game. Seeing as it sometimes causes the game to freeze when buying large amounts of cards from a vendor. The UK PS3 version also freezes when buying large amounts of cards. A possible work around is to first put all playing cards you already have in the backpack of a companion. Then buy the cards you want of a vendor and finally retrieve all already owned cards from your followers inventory.
 * Though the rules state no discarding may occur during the initial round, it is nonetheless possible to do so anyway. If you do, your opponent does not get a turn and you get to go again. By doing this you can stack your hand with whatever cards you want at the beginning and easily win every game.
 * After the game ends, when it says to press any button to continue pressing start and then hitting start again will cause the game to become unresponsive yet party chat still works.
 * It is not possible to discard cards from your hand once your main deck is empty. Your opponent will still be able to do so once their deck is gone.

List of NPCs who play Caravan

 * Ringo - Ringo also gives the Courier one of his spare decks, which allows you to play Caravan.
 * Johnson Nash (Some players experience that he usually only bets 1)(being a merchant, you can buy all his stock and then win the money back betting in caravan)
 * No-Bark Noonan (His highest bet is 1400)
 * Dale Barton - The Fort
 * Lacey - Mojave Outpost Barracks/bartender (Usually starts her bets high in the 500's and as you win, she'll lower her bets) (being a merchant, you can buy all her stock and then win the money back betting in caravan)
 * Jake Erwin - NCR Embassy
 * Dennis Crocker - NCR Embassy (First bet is usually at or above 1000)
 * Little Buster - Camp McCarran
 * Mayes - Quartermaster, Camp Forlorn Hope(has no stock to buy(Until you get permission from doing missions for the lieutenant), but still has 2000+ caps)
 * Isaac At Gun Runners.
 * Cliff Briscoe(being a merchant, you can buy all his stock and then win the money back betting in caravan)
 * Keith - Aerotech Suite 200
 * Jules- North Vegas Square

Behind the scenes
The achievement name "Know When to Fold Them" is an homage to the song "The Gambler" by Kenny Rogers, specifically the well-known chorus: "You got to know when to hold 'em, Know when to fold 'em, Know when to walk away, Know when to run. You never count your money When you're sittin' at the table. There'll be time enough for countin' When the dealin's done."