Rescue from Paradise

 is a Fallout 3 quest. It is also an Xbox 360/PC achievement and a PlayStation 3 Trophy.

Where To Receive the Quest
Note: If you manage to get in to Little Lamplight with a high speech skill before accepting the rescue quest, you will not be able to get the "Rescue from Paradise" quest from Little Lamplight. If you wish to initiate the quest here, use the non-Speech dialog option first, then immediately speak to MacCready again, taking the Speech option to get in. You can also use Speech to get into Little Lamplight and later rescue the kids from Paradise Falls, getting the trophy or achievement that way.

Your alternative would be to force your way through Paradise Falls (just go in guns blazing, you won't lose any Karma killing Slavers) and find Sammy usually hiding between a couple of cars near the main door to Paradise Falls. Talking to him and agreeing to help will activate the "Rescue from Paradise" quest.

Little Lamplight
To go through the Little Lamplight cavern without the Child at Heart perk or a sufficiently high Speech level, you have to speak with Mayor MacCready and agree to complete the Rescue from Paradise quest that he assigns you. Two residents of the town, Sammy and Squirrel, have been kidnapped by slavers from Paradise Falls and MacCready demands their return.

Paradise Falls
If you don't visit Little Lamplight first, you have the option to simply walk into Paradise Falls and talk to Eulogy Jones. He will tell you he has children for sale as slaves and that you should walk over to the pens and browse for ones you want. Upon doing so, Sammy will ask you to save his friend Squirrel and himself. Alternatively, if you decide to kill all of the slavers, the option to save the children in this quest becomes available as well. Interacting with one of the children gives you the quest.

Much more simply, you can tell Eulogy you're looking to buy slaves, then mention the kids, and he'll offer all three for 2000 caps (you can speech check it down to 1200). Simply buy them, go back to the exit, talk to the kids (they'll be convinced you're no good, but it won't matter) then leave and talk to them again. They'll run off to Little Lamplight, you'll both obtain and complete the quest, get the achievement, and it will all be done hassle free.

Pre-Requisite Quests
When you arrive at Paradise Falls, Grouse (the gate guard) asks you to capture slaves in order to gain entrance to Paradise Falls. If you agree, he will give you the Mesmetron and the locations of four "VIP" slaves that he wants you to find -- beginning the Strictly Business quest. Instead, if your speech is high enough, you can simply talk your way into paying 500 caps for immediate access, or if your karma is low enough you can be let in free of charge. There is also the option of forcing your way in through superior firepower, but it should be noted that interacting with Grouse and completing the Strictly Business quest is an Xbox 360, PC achievement and a PS3 trophy.

Saving Sammy and Squirrel
When you get inside Paradise Falls you have to go to the slave cage at the back of the area and talk to the kids through the wire gate. They tell you that you must open unlock the gate to the slave pen in order to rescue them. This can be accomplished either by tampering with the terminal in Eulogy's Pad (requires 50 Science) or rewiring a junction box near the bar (the area with the sign labeled Food) (requires Repair 40). Once this is completed, Squirrel tells you that the guard Forty needs to be distracted so they can make a run for it. The player has the option of talking to Forty and convincing him to walk away, or just killing him instead (which turns the entire camp hostile). You can also mez Forty causing the slave camp to turn against him but you being safe. Alternatively, you can talk to Crimson and either convince or pay her to seduce Forty. You can also convince Forty that he is not being payed enough through a speech challenge which will cause him to talk to Eulogy Jones and be away from the slave pen.

Saving Penny
Once this is completed, Squirrel will tell you that their friend Penny won't leave until her friend Rory is released from The Box. However, it is also possible to convince Sammy and Squirrel to abandon her if your Speech is high enough. At this point, the player can lie to Penny and tell her Rory is safe, tell her that "friends leave you sometimes", or find the key to the box and save Rory. Penny says you can pickpocket Forty or find it in Eulogy's Pad. Once you retrieve the key, Penny will leave and meet you outside with Sammy and Squirrel. Once the kids have escaped, Sammy tells you to meet him South-West of here. Speak to them again and they say that they are returning to Lamplight Cavern and will make sure that MacCready allows the Lone Wanderer to pass through.

Saving Rory
Once you open the box, you will notice that Rory is not a child, and realize that he won't fit in the sewer pipe like Penny, Sammy and Squirrel. You'll need to sneak him out through the front door. One way to get him out safely is to kill everyone in the city (Plan C).

You don't have to get Rory out of the town. You can get him out of The Box, tell him to follow you, immediately go back to Penny and tell her you've rescued him. As he tries to escape he will die, but Penny is already rescued.

It's possible to "rescue" Rory without turning the town hostile, as long as he does all the fighting. First, steal the ammunition (including grenades) from all the outdoor slavers, and collect all the melee weapons laying around. Next, you will have to give Rory a weapon and ammo. He is hopeless with energy weapons, but can handle a Combat Shotgun rather well. You will have to plant (reverse-pickpocket) it on him, and he will turn hostile if he catches you. He can use Stimpaks as well, so plant a couple on him. Don't give him anything too rare or expensive, as you will likely not be able to retrieve it. Now, when you tell Rory to run, he will be armed and the slavers will not. This gives him a fighting chance, although he still tends to freeze up and get beaten to death. Once he reaches the door to the outside, he is home free; Grouse and the other outdoor guard will not attack him. **Note: This strategy often fails because the two guys with super sledges usually beat Rory to a pulp. ***Note: Most of the slavers including the guys with the super sledges will be asleep at 0300, so thats the time to do it this way.
 * It should also be noted that occasionally, for unknown reasons, the Slavers will put away their weapons and assume an Unarmed fighting stance (possibly a glitch). If you notice any of the Slavers in this fighting stance, you can Pickpocket their weapons, leaving them Unarmed as you escape with Rory Maclaren. This is especially useful if you steal the Minigun from the sentry in the middle of Paradise Falls.

Another way to rescue Rory without turning the town hostile is to kill outdoor Slavers using empty barrel, ha-ha! Just take one by pressing 'Z' key and run on slaver. The slaver will be hit. Do it until slaver dies. This way you can clear the way to the gate for yourself and Rory! ;)

Another method is the running of the bulls strategy, where you get to Rory to follow you, and release the other 3 prisoners willing to escape from the pen simultaneously. With luck, You and Rory can make it to the gate while the other prisoners take the brunt of the enemy fire. This can be used in conjunction with looting of the slavers of their ammo.

If you're interested in actually saving Rory through cleansing the town, it is necessary to release him from the box before killing all of the slavers, or else, when you open The Box, he will be dead, though intact. The best method seems to be to free him at midnight from The Box, lead him to the far back corner of the now open Childrens' pen once they have run away, and have him wait there while you decimate the slavers of Paradise Falls. (Even having him wait in the open Box seems to work fairly well.) Then, simply lead him to the gate. There will be about 10 slavers awake at that time of night, depending on the difficulty level, and this will obviously turn the city hostile towards the player. It does not appear to be necessary to kill the two guards at the entrance to Paradise falls, as Rory talks to you at the town exit, at the end of which you gain Karma.

There is no reward besides Karma for saving Rory. He gains no new dialogue in his new home in Moriarty's Saloon.

Alternatives

 * 1) If you're willing, you can shoot your way through and carry out a "Town Slaughter" -- one of the rare instances in the game where such an act is karmically good.  One suggestion is to start with the guards in the front outside. Forty should run out also, allowing the player to shoot him and get his key. You will notice Sammy off to the side behind a car. Talk to him to start the quest. This is where it becomes harder. You will automatically get shot at by a man with a mini-gun so jump behind the metal plates right in front of the entrance. This method allows the player to gain the most experience out of the quest.
 * 2) Another suggestion is to start the fight from Eulogy's balcony. This allows the player to take out the mini-gunner first and easily kill the rest of the slavers from above.
 * 3) If you choose to gun your way out once inside (like after freeing Rory), a good tactic is to take the mini-gun tower immediately (you will have plenty of time to position your companions and take a shot before turning the town hostile -- allowing you to snipe, missile, or mini-gun the slavers from that position (similar to the plan from Eulogy's balcony). With decent V.A.T.S. (or even manual) accuracy, you should be able to clear out all the slavers as far away as the bar without them having time to get close or react. The only concern is the tendency for Dogmeat and other melee companions from running out into the fray.
 * 4) First speak to the kids who are locked up. Then make your way to Lock and Load (the gun store).
 * 5) Enter Lock and Load and kill Pronto, the owner. Once you have control of the building you can use it as a base. There is a bed in his room that can be used during your attack. You can keep entering and exiting the building without having an NPC follow you back inside. This means that you can keep exiting the building, killing as many people as you can, and re-enter back inside for cover. They will not follow you in. If you need guns/ammo, you have a nice stash. If you need a bed to rest in, you have it. If you want to just relax and look at the green glowing mushrooms downstairs in his room, you can as the NPCs should not enter the building. **NOTE**: Sometimes Clover and/or Jotun seem to be able to enter the building while you are killing everyone.  If they enter the building you will not be be able to heal yourself by resting in the bed. You will get a message stating you can't rest when enemies are nearby. But Once the two are killed the bed is usable again. If anyone else is able to enter Lock and Load while you're killing everyone, kill them and you should be able to use the bed again. TIP: Exit the building and drop some mines, then re-enter the building. This is one of the best times to use a Psycho/Med-X or any chem with +DMG on it. Doing this makes each individual fight quicker and less painful for you.
 * 6) If you have enough bottle caps and a high enough Speech Skill, you can simply buy the children from Eulogy Jones. He demands 500 bottle caps each for Sammy and Penny, and 1000 bottle caps for Squirrel. However, with a successful Speech challenge you can buy all three children for 1200 bottle caps total. You can then meet the children at the front gate to Paradise Falls and simply escort them outside. Speaking with Sammy will successfully end the Quest.

Bugs

 * If you enslaved Arkansas, disarming his collar and freeing him will cause him to produce a sniper rifle out of thin air (even if you took it from him when you enslaved him) and say he's going to join the Temple of the Union. Immediately afterward, he will kill Flak, Susan Lancaster, all slaves and raiders he comes in contact with (i.e. everyone in Paradise Falls aside from the Lone Wanderer).
 * There is a bug where if you kill Forty near the cages, it doesn't count as him being distracted. Multiple users have reported this.
 * There is a bug that causes Rory to freeze upon exiting Paradise Falls and/or follow the user everywhere he goes. To solve this, stand by the Paradise Falls exit and simply wait for Rory to get out of sneak mode and talk to you. If successful, he will then wander off by himself.
 * It appears that if you are particularly unfortunate while killing everyone in the town, some of the slavers will vanish upon death, preventing the player from looting them.
 * There is a bug that causes Rory to sink into the ground upon reload if asked to wait.
 * There is a bug that occasionally prevents the player from interacting with Sammy. If you cannot talk to Sammy right away, wait a little bit then walk forward and try again.
 * There is a bug that allows the user to complete this quest twice to get twice the amount of EXP. One user reported completing the quest by killing all the slavers and freeing the children -- with the full experience and achievement being acquired. Later in the game, upon attempting to gain access to Little Lamplight during the quest "Picking Up The Trail, Mayor MacCready mistakingly resumed the script that demands the user rescue the kids from Paradise Falls before he could pass through Lamplight Caverns. Afterward, the slavers and Penny had returned to Paradise Falls (Sammy and Squirrel weren't there and Rory was still dead in The Box). After speaking to the kids (who all appeared outside), additional EXP and access to Lamplight Caverns.
 * If you do the speech test or child at heart option to get past mayor Macready, then the quest still be completed by freeing the children slaves, regardless if you have the quest.
 * Shrapnel will appear in the box if you enslaved Flak during the Strictly Business quest.